Julianne Hough REVEALS Why Harry Shum Jr.'s DWTS Run Ended in Shock Elimination
The Dancing With the Stars cohost drops a bombshell theory about the unexpected exit that has fans talking
By CelebBuzz StaffNovember 18, 2026Source: E! NewsFact-Check: HIGH
She's Got Answers
When a fan-favorite gets the boot on Dancing With the Stars, there's always speculation. And this season? The chatter was LOUD.
Harry Shum Jr.'s shocking exit from DWTS season 35 left viewers reeling. The actor came into the competition with serious star power, and his partnership with pro Jenna Johnson seemed electric from night one.
But then came the elimination that nobody saw coming. And now, cohost Julianne Hough is stepping up with her own explanation for what really went down behind the scenes.
Hough has been in the DWTS world long enough to know the ins and outs of the competition. She's danced, she's won, and now she's commentating on the drama. So when she speaks, fans listen.
What's her theory? The answer might surprise you—and it could completely change how you view the elimination.
Keep reading to discover what Julianne thinks was really behind Harry's unexpected exit... →
PAGE 1 OF 4
The Setup: A Partnership That Seemed Unbeatable
Harry Shum Jr. brought more than just name recognition to the ballroom. The actor, best known for his role on Glee, is athletic, charismatic, and—let's be honest—easy on the eyes. Fans were already rooting for him before the competition even kicked off.
Paired with the talented Jenna Johnson, their early performances showed real promise. The chemistry was there. The technique was developing. Week after week, they were delivering solid routines that had judges and audiences engaged.
So how does a partnership that seems primed for success suddenly crumble? That's the question that's been plaguing DWTS enthusiasts since the elimination aired.
The Competition Heats Up
As the season progressed, the field got tougher. Other celebs stepped up their game. The judges' critiques got sharper. And Harry's performances, while consistently good, weren't always standing out in the increasingly crowded field of talent.
Then came the week that changed everything. The elimination happened faster than anyone predicted, and suddenly, Harry and Jenna's journey was over.
Fans took to social media with theories of their own. Was it the judges' critiques? A rough night? Bad luck? Or something deeper?
Julianne's insider perspective on what really happened might just settle this debate once and for all... →
PAGE 2 OF 4
Julianne's Bombshell Theory
As a cohost of DWTS, Julianne Hough sees everything that plays out on stage AND behind the scenes. She's watched countless celebrities rise and fall, and she knows what separates the ones who advance from the ones who go home.
When the cameras asked Julianne for her take on Harry's elimination, she didn't hold back. The cohost shared her theory about what ultimately led to his shock exit, and it's more nuanced than simple performance quality.
According to E! News, Hough's explanation touched on factors that go beyond just nailing the choreography. In a competitive field where every week brings new challenges, consistency, momentum, and the ability to connect with audiences all play crucial roles.
The Judge Factor
Julianne understands how the judges' scoring works intimately. She's stood in those judging seats before. And she knows that in DWTS, public voting combined with judge scores creates an unpredictable—sometimes heartbreaking—elimination dynamic.
Her theory addresses the reality that sometimes, even talented dancers can find themselves in the bottom two at the wrong time. And when that happens, it's not always about who's "better." It's about timing, momentum, and how well you've captured America's heart.
For Harry, Julianne's theory suggests that the elimination came down to factors beyond his control as much as those within it.
But here's what insiders are really saying about what happens next for Harry and Jenna... →
PAGE 3 OF 4
What Comes Next
Harry Shum Jr.'s DWTS journey may have ended sooner than expected, but his time on the show isn't without merit. He gave it his all, and that's what the competition is ultimately about—pushing yourself to grow as a performer.
Jenna Johnson, his pro partner, has worked with numerous celebrities throughout her DWTS tenure. She's experienced the ups and downs of the competition format, and she'll undoubtedly move forward to partner with another star in future seasons.
For Julianne Hough, continuing as cohost means she'll be front-row to all the shocking eliminations, heartwarming victories, and drama that the show inevitably serves up. Her insider perspective is what fans crave—the "why" behind the results.
The DWTS community has already moved on to the next round of eliminations, but Harry's fans haven't forgotten what he brought to the ballroom. And Julianne's theory may just be the closure viewers needed to understand that sometimes, it's just the nature of the game.
The dance floor waits for no one—but the memories remain.
This story is developing. Follow CelebBuzz for updates.
Originally reported by E! News. Fact-check confidence: HIGH